Strong Female Characters
Shamus:
Lots of movies have trouble coming up with a strong female character who isn’t just a short man with no personality. The example cited in the post was that of Abigail Whistler in the third Blade movie. She’s my favorite example of a hackneyed “strong female character†who emphasizes “strong†at the expense of “female†and “characterâ€.
Although this article is mostly about “strength” in terms of character definition, many of the comments also point to problems with the way physical strength is often handled. It is a simple fact that, on average, women are not as big and strong as men. There’s a reason most sports are divided into men’s and women’s division, even in as scrupulously egalitarian a venue as the Olympics and even in a non-contact sport like tennis. (Notable exception: Target shooting.)
And yet, many TV shows, movies, and anime show relatively small, lightly built women beating the bloody crap out of large, heavily muscled, trained men in hand-to-hand combat.
I deem this to be not only in violation of my suspension of disbelief, but actively dangerous in the real world, because it gives real girls and women utterly unrealistic expectations about their ability to defend themselves.
Also, see the article Shamus links to over at Bob’s Head. Regrettably, Bob doesn’t link to individual articles, so you’ll have to find the entry for Sunday 18 March 2007 (still on the front page as I write this).
Another, seen more often in serious mainstream dramas, but also seen in some genre fiction as well, is more insidious, and often gets to me worse than the Street Fighter Strong Woman model. There is apparently a belief that to be ’strong’, women must be confrontational, abrasive, and just generally no fun to be around. Thing is, this is just the emotional equivalent of the earlier problem - instead of beating people up with fists, these are women who beat people up with socially unacceptable behavior.
Another line path to failure is the a character who is of such density of skull that even repeated self injury does not change their basic assumptions about the universe. These are often angst ridden characters who have no real ability to deal productively with crisis, yet are labelled strong. This is often combined with ‘Physically Strong’ and called a ’strong woman’. The worst recent example I can think of this is Anita Blake. I have also seen it combined with ‘Emotionally abusive’, which winds up with the worst of all worlds, an abusive person with no real redeeming characteristics who is then posited as a role model.
Some observations of the behavioural patterns of Japanese and English-speaking anime fans
- English-speaking fans tend to approach an anime series through the application of reason and logic. Japanese fans tend to approach an anime series through the application of emotion and feeling.
- Research on topics like historic background, mythical symbolism are more common with English-speaking fans. If something is unclear, the tendency among English-speaking fans is to look it up, write it up and serve it up, whereas the tendency among Japanese fans is to let it pass.
- You may call it the Rational Western Mind at work: on top of research, English-speaking fans like to take a body of details and develop theories of how these details are connected. After gathering the who, when, what, where and how, English-speaking fans want to know the why. I must say - although I frequent Japanese and Chinese fandoms as well, the most interesting analysis I have ever read all come from English-speaking fans.
- The creative genius of English-speaking fandom lies in identifying and decoding of the elements of an anime. The creative genius of the Japanese fandom lies in fanart.
Via Beware the Kawaii.
Dammit, there’s another article I can’t find about anime studios being sweatshops. And not just for the animators, but the voice-acting talent. I’ll keep looking.